Mount Everett senior Nathan TenBroeck addresses Egremont's special town meeting.
Updated Saturday evening with a reaction from the 8 Town Regional School District Planning Board.
Updated Oct. 24: All Southern Berkshire towns except for Alford (106-23) voted down the merger; all three Berkshire Hills towns voted in favor by wide margins.
SHEFFIELD, Mass. — Egremont’s special town meeting Saturday morning overwhelmingly rejected a plan that would have merged the Southern Berkshire Regional School District with the Berkshire Hills Regional School District.
By a vote of 143-78, members said no to a new Southern Berkshire Hills Regional School District that would have joined the five towns in the SBRSD with the three in the BHRSD and eventually replaced the existing Mount Everett and Monument Mountain high schools with a new 9-12 school on the Monument Mountain campus.
The merger of the two districts was dependent on a positive vote in all eight of the proposed member towns. The other seven have scheduled their special town meetings for Monday, Oct. 23. Officials from the 8 Town Regional School District Planning Board have said those towns should go ahead with their meetings regardless of the outcome in Egremont.
Saturday morning's secret ballot vote came after about an hour of debate in the cafeteria at Mount Everett.
Perhaps the most emotional testimony came from a current senior at the high school.
“Student concerns have been overlooked and overshadowed by the planning board,” Nathan TenBroeck told a standing room crowd in the cafeteria.
TenBroeck said that students would not feel the same in a merged district and that they would lose their “sense of identity” and culture if forced to go to school at a new, merged high school.
“Students have been treated as statistics on a brightly colored graph for too long,” the 18-year-old TenBroeck said.
“Today is my first time voting, and I will gladly vote no on the merger.”
Several meeting members talked about the loss of community and identity if the Southern Berkshire towns lose Mount Everett, which had a student enrollment of 294 in grades 6-12 in the 2022-23 academic year, according to the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education.
One speaker said her daughter told her of friends who enrolled at Mount Everett after experiencing “bullying” at Monument Mountain.
Another, Ellen Maggio, dismissed dire warnings from the 8 Town committee of continued enrollment declines in the South County towns, telling the meeting that she had been hearing such predictions for the Southern Berkshire Regional School District for decades.
Maggio said that getting rid of Mount Everett would only accelerate any population loss in the region’s five towns.
“If we close our high school because we’re moving into a new district, I think there will be a giant sucking sound in Sheffield,” Maggio said. “We’ve built this school. We’ve built this community. Why would we give that up?”
The first speaker to the microphone when temporary Moderator Charles Proctor opened debate was the 8 Town committee chair, who gave a shortened version of merger advocates’ reasons why it makes sense to combine the two regional school districts.
Lucy Prashker, a resident of Alford, told the Egremont residents that the two regions combined have seen a 45 percent decline in enrollment since 2000.
“Especially for high school students, that’s a real challenge,” Prashker said. “It means a reduction in academic choices, extracurricular choices and social choices. We will be able to expand those choices by bringing together the best of both districts.”
And, she emphasized, the planned high school for the new merged region would be able to offer six Chapter 74 vocational programs. Currently, Monument Mountain offers three voc programs; Mount Everett has none, but students from the Southern Berkshire district can study vocational programs at Monument Mountain through the commonwealth’s School Choice program.
It is relatively easy to “choice” into the Great Barrington high school because it was built for 700 students, far more than the current 9-12 population in the Berkshire Hills Regional School District, 472 in the most recent academic year.
The proposed high school for a merged district would be built for 620 students; if the Berkshire Hills district ends up standing alone and builds a replacement for the current Monument Mountain, that school would be built for a target enrollment of 485, Prashker said.
That number drew a question from Egremont Select Board member Mary Brazie.
“Why is Berkshire Hills saying, ‘If we don’t get a merger, we will only build a high school big enough for Great Barrington and Stockbridge students?” Brazie asked.
Prashker explained that any school building project would be a partnership with the Massachusetts School Building Authority, which establishes a projected target enrollment for the communities served by a building – in the case of the Berkshire Hills district, Great Barrington, Stockbridge and West Stockbridge.
“I’m sure Berkshire Hills would be happy to build a bigger school,” Prashker said. “The 485 number is from the MSBA.”
Several meeting attendees, pointing to a provision in the proposed regional agreement that nullifies this week’s merger votes if the towns don’t approve bonding for a new high school by June 30, 2025, indicated the merger plan itself is motivated by a desire to get Great Barrington a new high school and have its neighbors help pay for it. The chair of the Egremont Select Board, George McGurn, told the meeting that he believes the total price tag for that high school is considerably more than the $100 million projected by the 8 Town committee.
Perhaps anticipating these arguments, Prashker said in her opening remarks that the proposed regional agreement apportions 10 percent of the cost for a new high school to the five current Southern Berkshire district towns; that number would rise 1 percent per year up to 15 percent after 2033, when the SBRSD’s “legacy debt” for capital outlays is retired.
“If you have a $500,000 home in Egremont, that means an additional $52 per year, assuming the new building costs $100 million,” Prashker said. “If the cost rises by 50 percent, that’s another $26 per year [for a $150 million building].
“That’s pretty reasonable, considering the benefit.”
In the end, the meeting members decided there is more benefit to preserving what Southern Berkshire Regional School District already offers.
And at least one of the members raised the specter that a merged district could spell trouble for the South Egremont School’s pre-kindergarten program.
Jared Kelly, who serves on Egremont’s Planning Board, reminded residents that the two-room schoolhouse has been threatened by the budget ax before and argued that the proposed regional agreement does not adequately protect existing primary schools.
According to the agreement, school closures could occur on an 8-3 vote of the newly formed School Committee with representatives from at least six of the eight towns voting in favor plus a majority vote in at least six of the eight member towns.
“Which three towns are going to step in to save the South Egremont School?" Kelly asked his fellow Egremont residents. “Wake up. We need an agreement that preserves our elementary schools.”
On Saturday evening, the 8 Town committee released a statement in reaction to Saturday morning's vote that emphasized the need to hear from residents of the other seven towns on Monday.
"We had hoped for a different result in Egremont," the statement read. "But everyone’s voice should be heard."
"If Egremont were the only town to vote no – there may be other options. We might go back to Egremont to ask their voters to reconsider based on the will of their neighbors. Or we might find a way to tweak the agreement to satisfy concerns. Or we might decide to explore the possibility of a seven-town region.
"We can’t know whether any of those options are viable without knowing where the voters in each of our 8 towns stand. And that is why it is so important -- whether you are a 'yes' or a 'no' — that you go to your special town meeting and vote."
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
Rain Slows Growth of Butternut Fire
By Brittany PolitoiBerkshires Staff
GREAT BARRINGTON, Mass.— Rain has slowed the Butternut Fire's growth but it's estimated at about 1,200 acres at this point.
"We want to start with some good news. Ground patrols are finding minimal new fire activity since this morning's rains began," the Great Barrington Fire Department posted on its Facebook page at 12:45 p.m..
"We want to reiterate that the rain will not extinguish the fire but it is helping to stop the spread. The weather has also delayed some of the drone operations — as a result we do not have an official size. What we do know — the growth has been minimal."
Fire Lt. Brian Mead earlier Thursday morning said the fire had seen some growth overnight but not to extent of Wednesday's surge. Fire was reported within a quarter mile of homes and was "stopped in its tracks." There are now more than 100 personnel on the ground and there has been one injury related to the fire, which he did not elaborate on.
"The rain will help to some extent but it will not extinguish the fire," said Mead. "We will remain on scene for the days and weeks to come but we still need your help. Please, please follow the local and state bans on outdoor fire. The last thing we need is another preventable fire."
At 4 p.m., the department reported that it will continue to operate under unified command with support from local, state, and federal agencies. Friday's operations will be scaled back with smaller crews and focused on monitoring and reporting.
At the last live update of the day, Mead said the fire would continue to be monitored and fire crews dispatched as needed.
"There is a lot of misinformation on out social media and we ask that you please, please rely on local official sites," he said. "Please avoid the areas and allow us to do our work."
The rain and smoke has made drone monitoring difficult so the exact size of the fire is not known; he estimated it grew about 100 acres over the past 24 hours.
Two rumors he dispelled were that the fire did not start at Camp Eisner. Mead said the initial location of the burn has not been identified but it did not start at the camp, which is occupied. Ski Butternut is also not in danger and that fire crews have kept the blaze to a safe distance.
A section of the Appalachian Trail has been affected and that area shut down.
Thursday's rain slowed growth and allowed crews to establish strong fire boundaries meaning that swaths have been cut and cleared to create fire breaks — which are holding.
At this time, no homes or structures are in immediate danger.
The fire near Brush Hill Road off East Mountain was first reported Monday evening. On Tuesday, it spread over 100 acres, and on Wednesday, it covered over 1,100 acres, expanding into Sheffield.
The town remains in a state of emergency, as declared by the Select Board on Tuesday, but first responders assure that Great Barrington is not in danger.
Firefighters were dispatched to three locations for concerns of fire extension into homes and in one instance, the fire was allowed to continue in a controlled state to a driveway and self-extinguished. They are aware of one injury from the fire and urge community members to avoid the area and leave firefighting to the professionals.
"More than 120 personnel are on the ground today fighting this fire," Mead reported on Thursday morning.
He said the day’s rain will help to some extent but will not extinguish the fire, explaining "We will remain on scene for the days and weeks to come."
At this time, the primary focus remains the protection of life and property, as patrols and alert residents identified some encroaching fire and stopped it in its tracks.
"We have strategically placed structural task forces, prepared to protect homes and property. Although they are staged and at the ready — there is NO immediate threat to residents," the department wrote in the 12:45 update.
"At the same time, crews have been working through the rain cutting fire breaks in the forest to further stop any expansion. Those control lines are holding."
Area residents can expect smoke to linger for the next several days. The Southern Berkshire Public Health Collaborative released guidance for the poor air quality, as it can worsen allergies and cause respiratory infections, especially for those with heart disease asthma, or other lung diseases.
Residents are urged to monitor air quality and symptoms, move outdoor activities inside, wear a KN-95 mask when outdoors, close windows and vents in homes, and use HEPA filters.
Even with recent rains — there is a burn ban in Great Barrington until further notice. Additionally, state officials are evaluating week by week for statewide bans.
"With an immense amount of appreciation, we are not accepting donations at this time. In true New England fashion — neighbors have truly helped neighbors," the department wrote. "We are grateful to the community for once again showing your support."
Mead urged the community to "please please follow the local and state bans on fire, the last thing we need is another preventable fire."
Rain has slowed the Butternut Fire's growth but it's estimated at about 1,200 acres at this point.
It's the largest wildfire in the Berkshires since nearly a 1,000 acres burned in Clarksburg State Forest. click for more
The town is in a local state of emergency as responders work to calm a wildfire spread over 100 acres near Brush Hill Road off East Mountain. click for more
Monument Mountain's Everett Pacheco took control of the race in the final mile and went on to a convincing Division 3 State Championship on Saturday at Fort Devens. click for more
With a handful of precincts not yet reporting, Davis was leading opponent Marybeth Mitts by 12,603 votes to 9,480, winning 55.5 percent of the vote at as the clock struck midnight.
click for more