PITTSFIELD, Mass. — The City Council opted against asking Waterstone Realty for an independent economic impact study on the proposed Walmart Supercenter at this time.
The council voted 6-4 against Downtown Pittsfield Inc.'s request to have the developer pay for an independent consultant to analyze the economic the project to build a 190,000 square-foot store at the William Stanley Business Park.
However, some councilors said they'd like a study done, once a proposal is made and the once the scope of the study is clearer.
"When we are looking at the impacts of the downtown, it is not the interest of a few retailers who may not be here tomorrow but it is what are the impacts in 10 to 15 years from now," Downtown Pittsfield Inc. President Jesse Cook-Dubin said, explaining the type of study he hopes will be done.
Cook-Dubin said his board was unable to come to a stance on the issue because he feels there are too many unknowns to evaluate the long-term impacts. His membership will do its own research in looking at what has happened elsewhere and will talk to the business community. But, the third piece is to have a study done specifically on the impacts of this project at this site.
"The goal is not to delay the project," Cook-Dubin said, advocating to let Waterstone know the city wants such a study ahead of time and not in the middle of deliberations about the specific project.
Council Vice President John Krol, however, says the city has no leverage at this point to request such a study. Once the developers propose a project, then the City Council can ask for such additional information when the council is asked to approve the special permit. He also doesn't want it to delay the project.
"I have no problem studying it but we want to avoid what is called paralysis by analysis," Krol said.
Ward 7 Councilor Anthony Simonelli said asking for a study now is "putting the cart before the horse" since at the moment there is no such proposal. Waterstone has announced its intentions but so far hasn't applied for the permits needed. Simonelli said the entire review of the permitting will take a while so there is no urgency to push for a study now.
"We don't need to hurry up to go nowhere," Simonelli said.
Ward 5 Councilor Donna Todd Rivers, however, said the economic impacts should be studied because the project is too important to the city.
"I see all of the short-term benefits people are talking about. But, I want more information on the long-term impacts in Pittsfield. I would rather have a short delay and get the answer right than make a big mistake," Rivers said.
But the scope of the study is unknown, as is the cost and the time it would take. Ward 4 Councilor Christopher Connell said the study should be done by an independent person, and not by the city, and should look at business turnover, sales increases and decreases at local businesses, traffic patterns, homes values, and more. He envisions a comprehensive study.
"This is much more intense than some people believe," Connell said.
The city hadn't required Home Depot to do such a study, nor Aldi, nor Price Rite, when those companies moved in, said Councilor at Large Peter White.
"We talk about being business friendly and it seems right now we are being protectionists," White said. "We just keep putting hoop after hoop in front of businesses. ... we are not being business friendly."
Councilor at Large Kathleen Amuso agreed, saying, "this is one more hurdle they have to pass because Walmart isn't everyone's first choice."
Meanwhile City Planner C.J. Hoss said the city can request an independent review and if the council wanted, the Office of Community Development can start looking for a consultant now. But, the council did not vote to send the request to the office.
"It would be best to wait and see what the developer submits," Hoss said, because that way there is more of a basis of the review.
He said, "typically developers don't provide a larger economic impact" but in this case the city could ask for one. He suggested letting the developers know that the city wants one and then having a consultant review the study submitted.
"We provide some guidance to the developers about what they may want to include to address issues that come out," Hoss said of the Office of Community Development.
Councilor at Large Melissa Mazzeo advocated for having the office ask Waterstone to commission the study and if they don't, that's a "black mark for them" when it comes the vote.
Mazzeo was joined by Rivers, Ward 3 Councilor Nicholas Caccamo and Council President Peter Marchetti in voting to request such a study but was outvoted by the rest of the council.
If you would like to contribute information on this article, contact us at info@iberkshires.com.
Your Comments
iBerkshires.com welcomes critical, respectful dialogue. Name-calling, personal attacks, libel, slander or foul language is not allowed. All comments are reviewed before posting and will be deleted or edited as necessary.
No Comments
State Launches Workforce Innovation Tour at Interprint
By Brittany PolitoiBerkshires Staff
Secretary of Labor Lauren Jones starts her statewide jobs tour at Interprint in Pittsfield on Monday. The colors in the signage were inspired by the Eras Tour.
PITTSFIELD, Mass. — The Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development kicked off its "revolutionary" workforce tour at Interprint and learned some about decor printing.
On Monday, the Healey-Driscoll administration launched the "MassHire 250 Workforce Innovation Tour" to celebrate local and regional workforce innovations across the state. From now until July, Secretary of Labor and Workforce Development Lauren Jones will visit each of the state's 16 MassHire regional workforce boards to hear about partnerships that fuel and sustain sectors.
"Berkshire companies are innovative in creating new possibilities," said David Moresi, chair of the Berkshire Workforce Board. "Technology and innovation are part of the Berkshires' industrious past, thriving present, and limitless potential."
In celebration of Interprint's 40th year in the city, state and local officials toured the surface design and printing facility and even participated in an ink matching exercise. With around 200 employees, the company sells its decorative papers and films worldwide and has seen several expansions.
"As I often say, workforce development takes collaboration and the network of organizations, community leaders, and workforce partners represented here demonstrates the partnerships that drive outcomes from career coaching and job training to employment," Jones said.
"That was demonstrated certainly by hearing some of the highlights shared during our tour of the partnership with MassHire and the employment and professional development outcomes that we see at a company like Interprint."
In a week, Massachusetts will join five other states in celebrating Patriots Day, commemorating the inaugural battles of the American Revolutionary War: Lexington, Concord, and Menotomy (Arlington). The workforce tour builds on the launch of Massachusetts 250, a statewide initiative to celebrate 250 years of America's independence and Massachusetts' revolutionary legacy.
Jones noted the Taylor Swift's Eras Tour inspired the signage.
The Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development kicked off its "revolutionary" workforce tour at Interprint and learned some about decor printing. click for more
This letter establishes a formal deadline for submitting a detailed plan to address the dust nuisance and notes that failure to comply with this requirement could lead to financial penalties and potential legal action.
click for more
For every question, the candidates will each have up to 1 1/2 minutes to answer, followed by 30 seconds each to rebut or follow up. The moderator can allow for further debate on a particular question if needed.
click for more
The mission of Hancock Shaker Village is to preserve the history of the Shakers and to educate the public about them, and the baby animals are a big contributor to that.
click for more